« Beyond the Shack | Main | The Essence of God: Sovereign Holiness or Love? »

Princeton & Propositions

Posted on Thursday, July 30, 2009 at 09:15AM by Registered CommenterSacred Saga Team in , , , , | Comments111 Comments


Charles Hodge  

During my seminary career, although I majored in New Testament, I spent much time studying, particularly Historical Theology, and more particularly Reformed Theology in America. (In fact I went on to do my Ph.D. in Historical Theology.) Although I studied at Dallas Seminary, considered the bastion of Dispensationalism I did not buy wholly into the system. Instead I fell in love with the Princetonians: Charles Hodge, A.A. Hodge and particularly B.B. Warfield of whom it has been said had the theological mind of a Charles Hodge and a Wm. G.T. Shedd rolled into one. It is also said that after Jonathan Edwards, Warfield was the greatest theological mind ever produced in America. Warfield particularly had a razor-sharp mind and studied the positions of his theological opponents so he knew what they believed better than they did. As a result he could spot weaknesses in his opponents’ positions a mile (or more) away. He did not resort  to name-calling, nor did he twist his opponents positions wB. B. Warfieldhen involved in argument. Rather like Irenaeus the great second century opponent of Gnosticism thought the best way to discredit an opponent’s position was to give it a full exposition, working out the hidden assumptions and propositions. When this was done the opponent’s position would fall under its own weight, as discredited. I loved the logic and the clear thinking and the closely integrated system. In short it was supremely rational. The Princetonians also had a reputation for a warm personal piety (See Andrew Hoffecker, Piety and the Princeton Theologians).

Twenty-five years ago, when I was just starting my career as a Professor of Theology and I was doing research for my Ph.D. dissertation I traveled to New York City to read the Briggs Papers housed in the Library of Union Theological Seminary across the street from Colombia University at Broadway and 122nd I spent two weeks pouring over Briggs’ personal correspondence. Charles A. Briggs was Warfield’s great theological opponent in the 1880’s and 90’s with whom he battled over the question of biblical inerrancy. During my research,  I discovered a darker side to the Princetonian tradition. That darker side involved an absolute devotion to the Westminster Confession as the pinnacle of theological achievement that could never be improved upon. Charles Hodge boasted that a new idea never arose at Princeton. Warfield, although a much better theologian than Hodge never wrote a systematic theology because he believed that his mentor’s Systematic Theology could not be improved upon. They adopted a mentality which Briggs labeled orthodoxism "Orthodoxism assumes to know the truth and is unwilling to learn; it is haughty and arrogant, assuming the divine prerogatives of infal­libility and inerrancy; it hates all truth that is unfamiliar to it, and persecutes it to the uttermost." St., near Harlem.

I also discovered a deep dichotomy between the head and the heart. Charles Hodge, as representative of the Princetonian position, displayed a great antipathy for any emphasis on the subjective nature of Christianity. At one point he stated: "The idea that Christianity is a form of feeling, a life, and not a system of doctrines is con­trary to the faith of all Christians. Christianity always has a creed. A man who believes certain doctrines is a Christian." (Biblical Repertory and Princeton Review 29:693.) This stress on the objective nature of the Faith has led to the charge that Princeton was rational­istic in its approach to Christianity. Numerous historians and theologians have contended that the Princetonians compartmentalized faith and life. For example, C. R. Jeschke states of the Princetonians:

 The strict compartmentalization of formal theology and the life of piety that came to prevail at Princeton reflected in part the growing irrelevance of traditional modes of thought and inherited statements of faith for the needs of the church in a rapidly changing world. The fact that Hodge and his colleagues, like most of their contempo­raries, were unaware of the sickness in the theological body, only permitted the condi­tion to worsen, and heightened the reaction of the patient to the cure, when its true condition was finally diagnosed. ("The Briggs Case", p. 56.)

Back to my discoveries in the Briggs papers, it was here that I saw the practical outworking of the Princetonian position. Briggs’ uncle, Marvin Briggs who had studied at Princeton Seminary had been soured on the whole mindset that surrounded the Princetonian pre-commitment to the Westminster Confession. Charles Augustus BriggsWhile studying in Germany he writes to Marvin, "I have one course . . . on System­atic Theology which seems to be your detestation. However the subject is treated differently from what you had at Princeton. Prof. Dorner goes back to the Bible as his first step . . ." (B. T. 1:27). Several months later he wrote: "It is unfortunate for you that you were educated at Princeton where there is an incarnation of doctrine and everything is looked on from that standpoint. Here in Germany . . . everything is looked upon from a scriptural standpoint. The only difficulty is there is too little reverence for Scripture as the Word of God and too great an exaltation of human reason as arbiter over it" (B.T. 1:42. Underscoring original, italics added). Later in the same letter he characterized Princeton's system as "pernicious."

 I also discovered that while the Princeton theologians themselves were able to maintain a warm personal piety with their commitment to the system, the graduates of Princeton were not. it is not too much to say that many even among the Old School read only the theological material of the Princetonians. This fact contributed to a cold creedal orthodoxy among a significant contingent of the Old School with its stress on pure doctrine. Even the great Greek grammarian Basil L. Gildersleeve, himself a Princeton graduate, decried the “baleful influence of Princeton” stating that there was from there “very little hope of a generous vivifying force” (Letter from Gildersleeve to Charles Augustus Briggs, Briggs Transcripts, 5.470 (Twelve ledger books hand-copied by Emilie Grace Briggs comprising a transcription of Charles Briggs’ personal correspondence, Union Theological Seminary Library). Many letters from Princeton grads were in Briggs’ correspondence. What comes through the written lines is a cold rational commitment to truth which touched the head but bounced off the heart.

 Why is this important for us today? Because we see the same spirit within the academic wing of evangelicalism. We see theology that has reduced the truth of God to timeless abstract propositions. A theology that puffs up the knower with pride that he or she is committed to the truth, and even reduces love as another proposition to be parroted rather than a relationship to be experienced.


Reader Comments (111)

"What comes through the written lines is a cold rational commitment to truth which touched the head but bounced off the heart.Why is this important for us today? Because we see the same spirit within the academic wing of evangelicalism. We see theology that has reduced the truth of God to timeless abstract propositions. A theology that puffs up the knower with pride that he or she is committed to the truth, and even reduces love as another proposition to be parroted rather than a relationship to be experienced."

I sat in a Bible study last night, the first in a series, taught by a good man whose passion is to take on the Muslim, Hindus, "false" religions in this world. His lesson concerned an attempt to put into others knowledge of what to say to others in a witness of the Gospel and presented our faith, Christianity, as indeed the only "truth" out there. At one point I raised my hand to ask "What is truth?", to which one fellow in the class then replied "The Bible!" and I noted such as being what most within our faith would say. "But didn't Jesus say," I continued, "that He, alone, was truth?" From there, in few words, (I do not wish to steal another man's pulpit nor make waves of discontentment in such arena) I spoke of our belief in the Biblical proposition of Christ "in" me and how either that is a reality or we are kidding ourselves, of how, when I witness, be it in a classroom or in any situation God brings before me, what I desire is for Jesus to come up "out of my belly" and speak for Himself. My head, of course, is still involved, but I do my best to give it unto the other....

August 6, 2009 | Unregistered Commenterjim

Dr. Sawyer, Amen!! As your former student and now a teaching professional in seminary, i dare say that this article represents one of the most influential concepts you've bequeathed to me. Bravo!

November 24, 2009 | Unregistered Commentersam tsang

This is one of the most incredible blogs I have read in a very long time.Your blog is great for anyone who wants to understand this subject more. Great stuff; please keep it up!

April 25, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterHairdresser Wynyard

<p>Tried many times, jimmy choo outlet he finally that big backpack with straps tied on a Mr Yip Kam years, jimmy choo outlet online tried many times before to a man in a coma unable to limp on his back on his palms, jimmy choo bags and Zhou Ya Yan teeth, leaning Flanagan crude crutches slowly straightened up, jimmy choo sandals every inch of the period could almost hear his bones cry. But in the end, or stood up,jimmy choo shoes although the body will immediately fall apart like a pain, Jimmy choo but he finally stood up. Is more difficult than stand up and move forward, right foot as long as a move, barely sticks to the left foot can be painful to tremble. </p>

June 29, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterJimmy choo

<p>The man's eyes and some confused, jimmy choo outlet online but saw his bloodshot eyes glowing, I felt some heart somewhere stability: ysl shoes at least this moment, he can not look at me. "I'm sorry, I'll be careful, jimmy choo outlet you hold back." Zhou Ya suddenly made some effort to give birth to, first, very carefully, jimmy choo bags Mr Yip Kam open flat on the ground in loose, tory burch outlet and then explore the backpack from the chest and clean out the chocolate water, wholesale jimmy choo a man handed his mouth. Mr Yip Kam long years of staring at chocolate, yves saint laurent shoes the reaction was coming from the confused, so bitter and dry with open mouth, tory burch bags the piece of brown with a little bit of food into his mouth. Because there is no saliva, tory burch wholesale and that almost of chocolate can not afford, so he carefully took a bow saliva, tory burch outlet online and soon opened the bottle, weakness, said: "Save our point..." obviously should be the sweet taste, Christian louboutin outlet melt in the mouth actually so bitter. Seems distant to those taste buds isolated from the outside, and slowly swallow, but also others such as into the Stomach.</p>

July 1, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterJimmy choo

<p>Yan Zhou Ya heard nodded, nike free tightening the water bottle. Simply because the pain of the arm movement can not successfully completed, nike direct shaking several times finally get. Mr Yip Kam strong flick of the heart, nike free 3.0 a closer look Zhou Ya statement. Zhou Ya made aware of his eyes, mens nike shox smiled, and we must act by finishing backpack turned. Mr Yip Kam on a hold of him, air jordan 2011 obviously he's still weak, do not know come from the effort, kobe shoes it is so firmly grasp the hand of the Week sub-statement. Zhou Ya Yan's face was twisted a bit painful. Mr nike caps Kam-year look more white, gently raise the Week sub-words of the arm, nike football shoes to see a bloody man's armpit. It is worn wound, a mess already been ruined shirt, kobe bryant shoes break in that area already, and faint to see swelling of the wound. Look at the feet of week sub-word, kobe 6 means of transport on heavy Flanagan Zhigan bifurcation did not even clean up some big thorn had been kobe vi shoes dyed pink. Mr Yip Kam years breathed and watch, wholesale kobe shoes sour heart abnormalities, to realize that going back weeks, air jordan 13 made his Asian descent. A look back, it is deformed under the weight of the car wreck not far away, zoom kobe v some living death this week of sub-words, in fact, kobe shoes 2011 it seems from a distance of only the fundamental struggle is irrelevant. But somewhere in very warm heart, nike shox for men it is too warm, so they give birth to some hopeless mood: the two of them, can escape? Even if there is nike shocks no strength to think, they all know to expect the rescue force, nike free 5.0 the possibility of how small a nook, and self-help...it seems so hard, really possible?</p>

July 1, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterJimmy choo

An article why people like articles, why the by all like, the reason is various, various aspects of reason is also different, in different good chapter is not the same, because their outstanding characteristic is not the same, because each passage attract readers are the characteristic of different, some articles are subject to attract people, some articles are content attractive, some people like the views of the author.

July 10, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterGucci shoes wholesale

<p>He only had someone to send flowers, zoom kobe v but never received. And stared for a moment, Mr Yip Kam called the secretary to find a vase of flowers planted, kobe shoes the amount of help desk began to see a thick dossier—but those words seem to float kobe bryant shoes in front of the general, he was a bit annoyed. Mr Yip Kam kobe 6 by the press with the index finger on the temple, and suddenly everything has a slip mens nike shocks from the palm manipulation of powerlessness, nike direct but I do not know what to do. In the end or be disrupted before the turn of events to Mr Yip Kam—hands and feet sigh in my heart, kobe vi shoes it seems much less their own strong imagination. Fortunately, when you see this bunch nike shoe outlet of flowers, but also a spiritual feeling—reply probably because the womens nike shocks effect of flowers it is a cure. Next day, wholesale kobe shoes Mr Yip Kam trapped in trench warfare like that every day, and weeks of sub-words to keep a kobe shoes 2011sensible distance ambiguous, in that right place trimmed with Mr Yip Kam nike shocks wonderful to sparkle every day life. Mr Yip Kam sometimes received in the market for some market intelligence, nike shock shoes most of them handwritten—this world nike free would someone actually used to keep paper books, or so ugly word—sometimes receive one or two strange books and sometimes a few of the complimentary ticket tea, of course, nike free 5.0 three days a bunch of tulips.</p>

July 28, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterChristian louboutins

<p>In the beginning I want to say just a girl look prettier, nike shocks play like. But slowly I felt I could not leave her, and insisted, nike shoe outlet and she together. And then I want to open, and she loves the money it! It does not matter! Although I was not any knowledge of ugly, nike direct but will make more money happens kobe bryant shoes. As long as I do not unlucky day, you can keep her day! As a thought, nike shock shoes I feel that God is not thin for me, finally I have the advantages can be attracted to like a woman. " Hearing this, mens nike shocks Zhou Ya statement was silent, after a long, kobe shoes hard shoulder and patted Chen Qiaosheng: "Congratulations!" Chen Qiaosheng Hey smile: "Do you kobe 6 remember to send copies of gift like. I want to keep a wife, have to spend money everywhere!" "Good! Why do zoom kobe v not you make out a list of Qin Yue, she likes what I sent it." "In the end is an old friend, kobe vi shoes and sure enough on the Road!" Chen Qiaosheng happily pulling out the phone, womens nike shocks "Xiao Yue ah, Zhou Ya speech to give something to both of us, wholesale kobe shoes see what you could not bear to buy up a list to me..." Zhou Ya made laugh, nike free ignore Chen Qiaosheng this Mangfu eyes, kobe shoes 2011 that his friends behind to go to a party to the blue sky to the hook and began to initiate nike free 5.0 stay.</p>

July 28, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterChristian louboutins

Downtime Due to Maintenance and Small Patch
Two days ago, all Tibia game worlds will be offline from 12:00 until 13:00 CEST approximately due to technical maintenance work at our American service provider. In addition, a client patch will be in.
We sell tibia gold for all 77 servers, fast and safe guaranteed. We will bank transfer tibia money to your bank :) . 8mins - 30min tibia gp,tibia gold delivery,amazing!
寓教于乐的游戏
You can purchase cheap tibia gold,cheap guild wars gold,gw gold,guild wars 2 gold,guild wars 2 money,guild wars 2 platinum,guild wars 2 farming,cheap rs2 gold here.
武汉婚纱摄影
Free runescape gp Trade is back, no password is required, unlike before, instead of having to login your runescape account to transfer runescape gold using our transfer methods, now we can trade any much of runescape gp from our stock account to your target account instantly since the trade limit is removed, after your cheap rs2 gold order is confirmed, please login to our 24/7 online live chat immediately for an instant ingame trade Face To Face, our specialists will tell you when and where to go, normally the whole process takes no more than 10 minutes!
衣服搭配
hqs

August 25, 2011 | Unregistered Commentertibiahqs

A wide range of Australian made UGG Boots and sheepskin leather products. All ugg boots are hand-made with Australian sheepskin leather.UGG Boots Australia - Range of Genuine UGG Boots: Classic Tall and Short UGG Boots at Great Prices. Huge Range, all with Fast, Free Delivery.Bryant, the gap in the purchase price of shoes in kobeshoes.cc! Zoom discounts and cheap to buy the lowest price every day Kobe Shoes.25 May 2011 – Nike Air Force 1,Air Force 1,Cheap Nike Air Froce 1 Shoes Sale Online With Low Price.Authentic Footwear online shop. Retro Nike Shox, Air Max, Nike Air Lebron Shoes, Nike Air Max with cheap price, 2011 new styles Shoes for sale online.Supra Shoes on hot sale now,we carry a large inventory from Supra Footwear, Including Supra Shoes,Supra Skytop And Supra Avenger,Supra Bandit,Supra Bullet.Kobe Shoes, NBA Shoes, Buy NBA Shoes Online!True Religions Brand Jeans - Shop online for the latest trends in denim and fashion.Official Beats by Dr. Dre headphone by Monster Cable from Dr. Dre, Lady Gaga andDiddy.Christian Louboutin,Christian Louboutins,Buy

August 29, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterli

<p>Moncler Outlet is all the children in the source or the commercial website, Moncler Online, Moncler jackets kids for baby to provide substantial discounts, made love to you. You and your family to pay the same value very small mass, their jackets can access can access. Coat is very soft, warm an outlet side deck? In addition, the  mens moncler jackets to improve ease of recognition, enhance the impression can be obtained. A set of different sizes,,, for their long hair short, whereby it is possible, if you use a car, you can get all kinds of color of moncler jackets womens . Anyone who has spent time with young people is always better to adjust your kids, or one of the smartest and may not be relevant to people know. To a child of a Moncler Outlet Online vest, or cattle for food if you are sewing machine, a layer in the bottom of the garment for infants to provide protection. These Moncler Online Outlet decorations can be great Moncler Outlet Store  ! Small customer is great! The patient's children, this Moncler Clearance action with a stethoscope small have a look the most important customers.</p>

September 8, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterMoncler outlet

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>